Mark Rzepczynski wrote “Does Trend Following Work?” for SFO Magazine in 2005, as president and chief investment officer of John W. Henry & Company. He answers by changing the question: there is no magic formula for following trends, and if there is no trend, a trend follower cannot make money. The holy grail is a good decision process.
His case rests on three points. Decisions under uncertainty are hard, so investors must, in Herbert Simon's word, satisfice: use fast and frugal rules and learn from the actions of others, which show up in prices. People are biased: they hold losers, sell winners and trust their own forecasts too much, so rules must hard-wire good behavior. And markets aggregate opinion into prices, which can be read as a signal, the trend, plus noise.
Trend following, then, is a filter: smooth out the noise to find the signal, and use risk management to limit losses when there is no trend. Cutting losses and holding winners makes the result look like a long option position, a straddle, with positive skew: the profits come when markets move to extremes.