Trading University

Events

2009 · Crash · Bubbles, Black Swans and Crisis Alpha

Momentum crash

When stocks turned up in March 2009, the worst losers of the crash rose fastest. A strategy that buys winners and sells losers lost 42% in March and 46% in April.

Market low
Mar 9, 2009
Momentum portfolio, Mar 2009
−42%
Momentum portfolio, Apr 2009
−46%
Losers vs. winners, Mar–May
+163% vs. +8%

What happened

A momentum strategy buys the stocks that have risen most over the past year and sells short those that have fallen most. Over long periods it has earned a premium, and it is related to trend following in futures.

By early 2009 the losers were banks and other companies near failure, and the winners were steady firms. When the market turned on March 9, 2009, the most beaten-down stocks rose fastest: some financial stocks doubled or tripled in weeks. From March to May 2009 the past losers rose 163% and the past winners 8%, by the count of Kent Daniel and Tobias Moskowitz. A portfolio long the winners and short the losers lost 42% in March and 46% in April.

Their study found the same pattern in the summer of 1932, when the same portfolio lost 61% in July and 74% in August: momentum crashes come when a crashed market turns up hard. Trend-following futures funds had a weak 2009 as well.

Who lost, who won

Lost

US stock momentum portfolioMar / Apr 2009−42% / −46%
Mulvaney Capital2009−5.9%

Momentum portfolio from Daniel and Moskowitz, “Momentum Crashes” (2016); Monthly net returns from Mulvaney Capital's factsheet.

Performance figures are as published by the firms named, whose records are on file with the CFTC. Past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results. Trading University is not an agent for any firm named and makes no offer to invest.

The record

Quantitative Momentum
Wesley Gray & Jack Vogel · Wesley Gray and Jack Vogel on how momentum works, and when it fails