Trading University

Events

1875 · Fraud · Bubbles, Black Swans and Crisis Alpha

The Collie frauds

A London cotton merchant raised millions with bills of exchange backed by no trade at all. When his firm failed, the banks that had discounted them took the loss.

Failed
June 1875
Firm
Alexander Collie & Co.
Liabilities
about £3 m
Instrument
accommodation bills

What happened

Alexander Collie & Co. traded cotton between Britain and India. To raise money, the firm drew bills of exchange, promises to pay that banks bought at a discount, on firms that were its own associates. No goods stood behind them.

Banks in London discounted the bills as if they financed real trade. In June 1875 the firm failed with liabilities of about £3 million, and Collie fled. Several banks that had bought the bills took large losses.

Arthur Ellis, writing in 1879, used the case as a lesson in how credit expands until it breaks.

People

The record

The Rationale of Market Fluctuations (3rd ed.)
Arthur Ellis · Arthur Ellis on the Collie case