Trading University

Events

1901 · Corner · Bubbles, Black Swans and Crisis Alpha

The Northern Pacific corner

Two railroad empires bought every share of Northern Pacific they could find. Short sellers could not deliver, the stock hit $1,000 and the rest of the market crashed.

Date
May 9, 1901
Northern Pacific, intraday
$1,000
Before the fight
about $110
Settlement
Northern Securities Company

What happened

E. H. Harriman of the Union Pacific, backed by Jacob Schiff of Kuhn, Loeb, wanted a share of the Burlington railroad, which James J. Hill and J. P. Morgan had bought in 1901 through the Northern Pacific. In the spring of 1901 Harriman's side bought, without announcement, Northern Pacific stock to take control. When Hill and Morgan saw it, they bought too.

Traders who did not know about the fight sold Northern Pacific short as it rose. Between the two camps almost every share was locked up. On May 9 short sellers bid any price to cover, and the stock touched $1,000. To raise cash they sold everything else, and the market crashed.

The two sides agreed to let the shorts settle at $150. That year they combined their holdings in a new company, Northern Securities. In 1904 the Supreme Court ordered it broken up under the antitrust laws.

Jesse Livermore, then a young trader, had taken a profit in Northern Pacific weeks before. On May 9 he was short other stocks, and the slow ticker turned what should have been a profit into a loss.

Puck cartoon of J. P. Morgan as a bull in a checked suit blowing bubbles of inflated values while a crowd of investors leaps to catch them
Udo Keppler, Wall Street Bubbles — Always the Same, Puck, May 22, 1901, two weeks after the corner: J. P. Morgan as a bull blowing bubbles of inflated values. Library of Congress, Prints and Photographs Division.

People

Ideas

The record

Reminiscences of a Stock Operator
Edwin Lefèvre · Livermore's account of May 9, 1901