2008 · Fraud · Bubbles, Black Swans and Crisis Alpha
Bernard Madoff
For decades a former Nasdaq chairman paid steady returns that came from new investors' money. The statements showed $64.8 billion that did not exist.
- Arrested
- Dec 11, 2008
- Paper balances
- $64.8 bn
- Cash lost by investors
- about $17.5 bn
- Sentence
- 150 years
What happened
Bernard Madoff ran a respected market-making firm in New York and had served as chairman of the Nasdaq. He also managed money for charities, banks, funds of funds and wealthy families. His statements showed gains of about 1% a month, almost never a losing month.
There were no trades. Madoff paid withdrawals with money from new investors. In 1991 Edward Thorp examined the account statements of a client invested with Madoff and found that the trades could not have happened; the client withdrew. From 2000 on, Harry Markopolos, a fund analyst in Boston, told the SEC several times that the returns were impossible. The SEC examined the firm and found nothing.
In late 2008, as investors asked for $7 billion back during the financial crisis, the money ran out. On December 10 Madoff told his sons the business was “one big lie.” They reported him, and he was arrested the next day.
He pleaded guilty to eleven counts and was sentenced in June 2009 to 150 years in prison, where he died in 2021. The court-appointed trustee, Irving Picard, recovered more than $14 billion for investors. In 2009 the SEC's inspector general reported how the agency had missed the fraud.
Who lost, who won
Lost
| Paper balances on Madoff statements | $64.8 bn |
| Cash put in and not withdrawn | about $17.5 bn |
Figures from the court-appointed trustee.
People
- Bernard Madoff · founder
- Harry Markopolos · warned the SEC
- Ed Thorp · spotted it in 1991
- Irving Picard · trustee
Ideas
The record
Diana Henriques
Edward Thorp
- Also in The Black Swan (2nd ed.) (Nassim Taleb); Trend Following (Michael Covel); Adaptive Markets (Andrew Lo); Bubbles, Crashes and Financial Disasters (Ralph Lyons); Booms and Busts: An Encyclopedia of Economic History from Tulipmania of the 1630s to the Global Financial Crisis of the 21st Century (James Ciment (editor)); Manias, Panics, and Crashes: A History of Financial Crises (Robert Z. Aliber, Charles P. Kindleberger and Robert N. McCauley)
- Official SEC Office of Inspector General: investigation of the failure of the SEC to uncover Madoff's Ponzi scheme, executive summary, August 31, 2009 (PDF)