2007 · Blowup · Bubbles, Black Swans and Crisis Alpha
Quant quake
In the second week of August 2007, many computer-driven stock funds lost years of gains in days while the market moved little.
- Dates
- Aug 6–9, 2007
- Goldman fund rescue
- $3 bn
- S&P 500 that week
- little changed
- Study
- Khandani & Lo
What happened
By 2007 dozens of large funds ran similar computer models that bought some stocks and sold others short, betting on small price gaps between them. The market's direction did not matter; the bets were designed to cancel it out.
In early August, as subprime losses mounted, at least one large fund began selling its positions at speed. Because the other funds held the same stocks, the selling pushed against all of them. From August 6 to 9 they lost day after day, while the S&P 500 moved little.
Goldman Sachs's Global Equity Opportunities fund lost more than a quarter of its value and received $3 billion from the bank and outside investors. Renaissance Technologies and AQR also took losses. Most of the prices snapped back the following week.
In a 2007 paper Amir Khandani and Andrew Lo of MIT rebuilt the episode and showed how crowding into the same trades made it possible.
The trend-following record
The summer of 2007 was hard for trend followers as well, before the gains of 2008.
Lost
| Mulvaney CapitalJuly 2007 | −16.9% |
| Mulvaney CapitalAugust 2007 | −19.4% |
Monthly net returns from Mulvaney Capital's factsheet.
Performance figures are as published by the firms named, whose records are on file with the CFTC. Past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results. Trading University is not an agent for any firm named and makes no offer to invest.
Ideas
The record
Andrew Lo
Gregory Zuckerman
- Also in Efficiently Inefficient (Lasse Heje Pedersen); “The Self-Organized Criticality Paradigm in Economics & Finance” (Jean-Philippe Bouchaud)