Trading University

Library

Source

“The Self-Organized Criticality Paradigm in Economics & Finance”

Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, 2025

Jean-Philippe Bouchaud's “The Self-Organized Criticality Paradigm in Economics & Finance” is a review he wrote, at the request of Doyne Farmer, for The Economy as an Evolving Complex System IV, a Santa Fe Institute volume. Bouchaud, a physicist, is chairman and chief scientist of Capital Fund Management in Paris. A first version appeared on arXiv in July 2024; the version posted to SSRN is dated October 25, 2025.

Self-organized criticality is Per Bak's idea, from 1987, that many systems drive themselves to the edge of instability, like a sandpile that grows until one added grain can set off a slide of any size. Near that edge, small shocks can cause large disruptions, fluctuations have fat tails, and their effects last a long time. Bouchaud asks whether this explains two puzzles: the economy swings more than its shocks would suggest, and, as Robert Shiller showed in 1981, stock prices move far more than the dividends that follow justify.

In markets he finds the signs of a system near its critical point. Daily returns have fat tails; volatility clusters and has a long memory; and most large price jumps come with no news. Models of how past volatility feeds future volatility, fitted to market data, put markets close to the point where that feedback would run away. He sets out several possible causes. One plausible explanation, he writes, is liquidity: market makers compete their spreads down to break-even, so when volatility rises they widen spreads and pull back, which raises volatility further. He adds that the mechanisms are not known. Others are an ecology of value investors, trend followers and noise traders, and contagion among funds with overlapping positions, as in the quant crunch of 2007.

His conclusion is that efficiency and resilience pull against each other: optimizing a system pushes it toward a fragile edge, as just-in-time supply chains and thin market-making margins show. Regulators and policy makers, he argues, should count robustness to small shocks and extreme events among the things they optimize, at some cost to performance, in the spirit of Nassim Taleb's antifragility. He states that the case still rests more on narrative than on hard evidence. Rebellion Research reviewed the paper on November 17, 2026.

Read the paper (SSRN)

Events it covers