Trading University

Events

1974 · Bank failure, currency · Bubbles, Black Swans and Crisis Alpha

Herstatt and Franklin National

Two banks lost heavily betting on currencies after fixed rates ended; Herstatt's closing before its dollar payments went out gave settlement risk its name.

Herstatt losses
DM 470 m
Herstatt capital
DM 44 m
Herstatt closed
Jun 26, 1974
Franklin National closed
Oct 8, 1974

What happened

After fixed exchange rates broke down in 1973, currencies floated, and banks traded them for profit. Bankhaus I. D. Herstatt of Cologne, founded in 1955, bet the wrong way on the dollar. By June 1974 it had lost about DM 470 million, against capital of DM 44 million.

On June 26, 1974, German regulators closed the bank at the end of the German banking day, while banks in New York were still open. Banks that had paid Herstatt Deutsche marks that day were still owed the dollars due to them in New York. The consortium standing behind Herstatt at first meant to pay only German creditors, and then paid the foreign banks too. The risk that one side of a currency trade is paid and the other is not has been called Herstatt risk ever since, and before the end of 1974 the central banks of the Group of Ten formed the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision.

In New York, Franklin National Bank, controlled since 1972 by the Italian financier Michele Sindona, had also lost money on currencies. In May 1974 other banks stopped dealing with it except at penalty rates, and the Federal Reserve lent to it while a buyer was sought. It was closed on October 8, 1974, with about $3.6 billion in assets, then the largest bank failure in the FDIC's history. European-American Bank took over its deposits.

Who lost, who won

Lost

Bankhaus Herstattcurrency trading, 1973–74about DM 470 m
Franklin National Bank$3.6 bn in assetsfailed

As reported.

People

Ideas

The record

Manias, Panics, and Crashes: A History of Financial Crises
Robert Z. Aliber, Charles P. Kindleberger and Robert N. McCauley · On both failures and on the Fed acting as lender of last resort to Franklin