Trading University

Events

1993 · Blowup · Bubbles, Black Swans and Crisis Alpha

Metallgesellschaft

A German industrial company's US unit promised to sell oil at fixed prices for ten years and hedged with one-month futures. When oil fell, the margin calls came to $1.3 billion.

Positions
about 160 m barrels
Oil, 1993
about $20 → $14
Loss
about $1.3 bn
Positions closed
Dec 1993

What happened

In 1992 and 1993 MG Refining & Marketing, the US arm of Metallgesellschaft, sold heating oil and gasoline to customers at fixed prices for up to ten years. To hedge, it bought short-term oil futures and rolled them forward each month. At its peak the position equaled about 160 million barrels.

Through 1993 oil prices fell, from about $20 to $14 a barrel. The futures lost money every month and had to be paid for in cash, while the gains on the long-term contracts would come only over years. Other traders could see the monthly rolls coming.

In December 1993 the parent company's new management closed the positions. The loss was about $1.3 billion, and German banks had to rescue the company. Academics argued for years over whether the hedge had been sound.

Michael Covel asked a different question: who was on the other side? Trend followers had been short oil through 1993, and the CFTC records show the year was one of their best.

Who lost, who won

Lost

Metallgesellschaft1993about $1.3 bn

Won

Mark J. Walsh1993+74.9%
Chesapeake Capital1993+61.8%
Dunn Capital, WMA1993+60.3%
Eckhardt Trading1993+58.0%
Rabar Market Research1993+49.6%
John W. Henry1993+46.9%
Abraham Trading1993+34.3%
Man Investments1993+24.5%

From Michael Covel, Trend Following, Table 4.9.

Performance figures are as published by the firms named, whose records are on file with the CFTC. Past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results. Trading University is not an agent for any firm named and makes no offer to invest.

People

Ideas

The record

Trend Following
Michael Covel · who was on the other side: Tables 4.8 and 4.9