Idea · Bubbles, Black Swans and Crisis Alpha
Mr. Market
Prices swing with mood; Graham's parable for using the market's quotes, not obeying them
Benjamin Graham's parable, from The Intelligent Investor (1949). You own a share of a business with a partner, Mr. Market, who each day names a price at which he will buy your share or sell you his. Some days he is euphoric and quotes a high price; other days he is gloomy and quotes a low one. You are free to trade with him or to ignore him.
Graham's point was that the quote shows Mr. Market's mood, not the value of the business. James Grant's Mr. Market Miscalculates (2008) applies it to the bubble years: Cisco was valued at $485 billion in early 2000 and at $85 billion eighteen months after that.
Graham bought from Mr. Market when prices fell well below value, the margin of safety. Trend followers make no estimate of value and follow the direction of price. Both set their rules in advance, so the mood of the day does not decide.
Shows up in
- 1929 Crash of 1929
- 2000–2002 Dot-com bust
- 2007–2009 Financial crisis