Source
“Learning to Love Investment Bubbles: What if Sir Isaac Newton Had Been a Trendfollower?”
Mebane Faber, 2011
Mebane Faber's paper “Learning to Love Investment Bubbles: What if Sir Isaac Newton Had Been a Trendfollower?” appeared in Cambria Quantitative Research in September 2011. It starts from the South Sea Bubble: the stock began 1720 near £100, rose to almost £1,000 and fell back to about £100. According to Newton's niece Catherine Conduitt, he lost £20,000.
Faber then takes twelve bubbles in stocks, currencies and commodities compiled by James Montier of GMO. Across them, buying and holding produced meager returns with average volatility of 22 percent and an average drawdown of 66 percent. He tests one rule: hold the market when its price is above its 10-month simple moving average, and step aside when it is below.
The rule improved returns in eleven of the twelve bubbles and cut volatility and drawdowns in all twelve. On average it added about two percentage points a year, cut volatility by about 25 percent and cut the maximum drawdown by 30 to 40 percent. Applied to South Sea stock from 1719 to 1722, it suffered a 44 percent drawdown but ended with about four times its money, where a buyer who came in late, as Newton did, faced a loss of about 90 percent.
Events it covers
- 2007–2009 Financial crisis
- 2000–2002 Dot-com bust
- 1720 The South Sea Bubble